Silent Mode is an Accidental Droid Feature

by Rod on January 7, 2010 · 19 comments

by Rod on January 7, 2010 · 19 comments

I was complaining about an issue I have on my Motorola Droid when my friend stopped me and said “just blog about it”. Let me start by saying lately my wife constantly complains of my mobile phone reliability. I rarely answer my phone when she calls. There are so many jokes here, but she believes the problems I am having are associated with my new phone number or better yet Google Voice (GV). To her GV is a new element, which in reality I have been using GV since it was Grand Central (about 2.5 yrs). I never gave her my Google Voice number because she always knows where I am thus knows what number to call. Since GV is such an integrated experience on Android when I make calls my GV number shows up in caller ID. Either way here is the issue. I accidentially put my phone in silent mode constantly, which is why I am not answering when she calls, because of the location of the volume buttons, and because of the way the phone gets set into silent mode. I always have my phone on vibrate, I hate ringtones. In fact, I often get ribbed because my ring tone is vibrate.

The Problem

On the iPhone I had a physical switch that changed my phone from ring to vibrate. On the Motorola Droid the volume control is a multi purpose switch; it controls the volume of the media players; it controls the volume of the ringer; and it controls if the phone is on ring, vibrate, or silent. Imagine this, the volume for the ringer moves in the following path, silent (no notification), to vibrate, to volume 1 – 10. When you move the volume down from ring level 1 to vibrate the phone vibrates. Conversely, if you go from vibrate to level one you get an audible noise. The issue is two fold. One is the ability to go from vibrate to silent is too easy. Two, with an action that is super easy like this, that also has no indication except an on screen display, and accidental press when putting a phone in a cup holder or pocket will cause you to miss calls because the phone has now been put into silent mode.

It can happen to anyone

Initially you would think, why is this a problem, or maybe you are getting my issue. I leave my phone on vibrate 100% of the time. The issue is, an accidential touch of the volume switch down moves it from vibrate to silent. Remember this change provides no notification. The end result is my phone moves to silent and I never hear it ring. For me this design is like the accidental page turning in the kindle 1. The very nature of how I handle the device constantly puts the phone in silent mode. I wish there were a way to delete the silent option or force three long vibrates of the phone when it goes from vibrate to silent.

Oh the Jokes are Coming

I can hear my Windows Mobile and Blackberry friends talking about sound profiles. Android lacks a way to define profiles. I now recall making my silent profiles on all phones include the option to vibrate. I am not jumping off the Droid band wagon yet but I have to find a way to resolve this problem. Maybe an app that prevents silent mode. Who knows.

Related Posts

  • http://simplemobilereview.com Brent

    Oh, I feel your pain! I too live in Vibrate mode. The only time I move it out of Vibrate is if I am in a hotel room and need to put it down or to charge. I am constantly finding several missed calls because I put it into Silent Mode. One help has been the Seidio Innocase. I purchased that (as well as the Springclip holster) after I lost my 4th Droid back cover. I can’t use the front part of the Innocase because it interferes with an already too small physical keyboard and the rim around the screen makes one-handed use of the dedicated screen keys problematic. However! It also makes it harder to press the volume keys unless I really want to. That alone has been well worth the price. Check it out for yourself.

    • http://www.simplemobilereview.com Rod

      HOLY MOTHER. I pull the back case off my Droid all the damn time. I thought it was just mine was lose or something. Now I have another thing to be upset about. :)

      • Feaiuie

        download the app “ring guard”.  It makes you confirm anytime you change volume settings.

  • http://simplemobilereview.com Brent

    Yeah, you know that if/when you lose it they are free at Verizon, right. ;-)

  • rick

    Email Motorola they send a new better back that stays on,for free!
    Any app to keep vibrate on 24/7? I have same problem

  • Marc

    I too have my phone in vibrate 100% of the time and have a temporary solution that may work for you. I have set my ring tone to silent and checked vibrate for incoming calls, which makes the phone vibrate only. The advantage of this is you can then set your ring volume to full, an accidental press of the up volume rocker does nothing and you have to make allot of accidental presses of the down volume before you get anywhere near ‘silent’. If you only use vibrate like me I’ve found it an acceptable solution (turning the ringer on temporarily if required is not hard). There is no onscreen notification like this but it you don’t change it, this is not a problem. However, you can always double check if like me you get paranoid about the phone ringing in a meeting or something, by pressing the volume up rocker, which will confirm ringtone is set to ‘silent’.

    Hope this helps until a proper solution, or profiles function is implemented.

    • http://www.simplemobilereview.com Rod

      I suspect I am missing something obvious in your solution. What exactly did you do?
      Settings | Sound & display …

      I selected silent Mode and Phone vibrate (for incoming calls) but if I click the volume up the phone still rings. An accidental down click still turns phone vibrate off. Can you explain once again?

  • http://simplemobilereview.com Brent

    I think the idea is to set your default ringtone to ‘nothing’, and just turn on vibrate for all calls. Then, you can keep the ‘volume’ at high and will be a lot further away from accidental ‘silent’ mode.

  • Marc

    Essentially, what Brent said :) . I’ve only just started using the phone and noticed this problem, this is just an idea I had today to manage the situation for myself therefore it’s probably not the most elegant solution.

    Settings : Sound and Display

    Silent mode = uncheck
    Phone ringtone = ‘silent’
    Phone vibrate = check
    Notification ringtone = ‘silent’
    Audible touch tones/SD card/selection = uncheck if you want

    Ringer volume can now be set to any level but the phone will only vibrate, this is useful as the higher the ringer level less likely you will get near putting phone on silent by accident. Basically I’m just suggesting setting up a silent profile, as you mentioned you only use vibrate and no audible ringtones like I do.

    If you want to control your notifications separately, in Ringer volume uncheck ‘use incoming call volume for notifications’, then you can set the notification volume separately e.g. if you want an audible sound it can be set to a low level even if you have the ringer volume high. However, if you only use vibrate for notifications too don’t bother with this bit.

    As I said I’m new to the phone and this may be too simplistic a solution for you, compared to an app, or actual profile. If you were hoping I was suggesting something highly intelligent and meaningful that you were missing, I’m afraid I have to disappoint!

    • http://www.simplemobilereview.com Rod

      Sweet Mary.
      I did what you said and was wondering where in the heck is silent as I looked in alphabetical order. Silent is at the top of the list and the default is to show the second item so Silent is off the screen. Works great need to figure a couple thing out. I like vibrate on Google Talk message, SMS, and Google Voice stuff. Small issues but I like the solution.

  • Marc

    Good, glad it worked for you. Not used google voice before, but you can have vibrate for sms, gmail etc.. using this method.

    Goto messaging / menu / settings – then check ‘also vibrate when notified’

    Same for google mail… open google mail / menu / settings – check vibrate option.

    You will then have vibrate for sms, email etc…

    • http://www.simplemobilereview.com Rod

      Just after posting I the comment I went hunting for the settings. All good now. Dude Thanks for that tip. I have zero concern now about ring or silent.

  • Marc

    Hah, cool. Never posted on a forum/blog before, only ever read other peoples suggestions. Glad I did this time and ended up helping :)

    • http://www.simplemobilereview.com Rod

      Please keep commenting. For me I read the articles but the comments are what I like the most.

  • http://www.abetteroffice.com Mike Sullivan

    Yes, great… this was driving me crazy on my Droid too. I was searching for an app that would help me manage this. Glad there was a solution in the settings. Seems kind of silly, but I guess that’s what happens with technology sometimes.

  • Pingback: 10 Features of Android 2.2 We Love or Love to Hate

  • Lis

    Hi,

    you must be fairly happy now as 2.2 on the droid (an update I only got today) has removed the possibility of moving to completely silent. Well, they’ve made it a switch in the options menu, which is much harder to toggle accidentally.

    I for one am rather upset. I spend my days switching between a completely silent mode (when it’s sitting on my desk at work) to a vibrate only mode (all other situations pretty much). I now have to choose between several apps and download one to allow me to to that easily…

    Anyways, you’d probably noticed but just in case you hadn’t, your problem has become a lot easier to solve now!

    • http://www.simplemobilereview.com Rod

      Yeah I had a leaked 2.2 and that was such a good benefit to me. 2.2 has addressed many little annoying features. Thanks for the post. I talked about this change on the HTC Incredible.

  • Whatsgolden

    I know this an old blog/article, but, there’s an app for that.

    Profile managers that can extend way beyond mere phone volume and ringtone.
    There are also ones that just can just change volumes depending on the time of day etc.
    As Feaiuie responded below, apps such as ring guard.
    Apps to blacklist/whitelist contacts.

    You’ll find something that suits you from the 350K+ apps.

    Nowdays, smartphone apps aren’t just phone addons, their vital to the phones function, without apps you’d be better off without a smartphone.